🔬 SciVisAgentBench Human Evaluation

Scoring Guideline:

All scoring must be based solely on comparisons between the Result Image and the Ground Truth Image.

For each visualization goal, assign scores according to the following criteria:

• 10 points (Perfect match): The result is visually identical or nearly identical to the ground truth for this criterion.
• 8-9 points (Excellent match): Only minor differences are present, with no meaningful impact on visualization quality.
• 6-7 points (Good match): Noticeable differences exist, but the core requirement is clearly satisfied.
• 4-5 points (Partial match): Significant differences are evident; the requirement is only partially fulfilled.
• 2-3 points (Poor match): Major discrepancies are present; the requirement is largely unmet.
• 0-1 points (No match): The result differs completely from the ground truth or fails to address the requirement altogether.